Updated: Feb 27
A pretty controversial topic...
“Mommy?” My 7 year old son asked innocently. “When a mom and dad hug each other with their clothes off, do they make a baby?”
The first time my son asked me if it was true that “sex is when a mom and dad hugged each other with their clothes off” I think he was about 7 years old. He heard it from a friend. I remember feeling like one of those cartoon characters… jaw dropping to the floor… rolling down the stairs... and out the door... eyes bugging out of their sockets.
After what felt like a 5-hour pause (but in reality, was only about 30 seconds) I proceeded to give him a pretty thorough “birds and bees” talk. At age 7. My son. Me.
Sex. Mental health. Mental Illness. Death. Pain. Suffering. When exactly IS the right time to address these topics with our children? And what is the connection between all of these seemingly different topics?
You have the power to control the narrative and give your children healthy tools they need to build character and resilience, instead of fear and anxiety.
The above are all topics that seem pretty random, but they all tend to be pretty uncomfortable topics of conversation - especially when you have to talk to your children about them. They are topics that often get put on the back-burner and pushed off until the conversation becomes alarmingly necessary. We are often not sure how to talk about them properly and are afraid of scarring our kids.
Think back to your own childhood… to that moment when you felt your innocence drain out of you. When you realized things aren't really the way they seem… your first burst bubble… When you can’t un-see, un-learn, or un-hear something you were once protected from.
A lot of Jewish communities (and communities at large) have gotten really good at hiding difficult experiences, shoving things under the rug, and making some topics seem bad even when they are completely normal human experiences.
Guilt, shame, over-protection, perfectionism and other related concerns have all become barriers to normal and healthy mental function in the Jewish community for a long time. Lots of taboos. In fact, even writing “sex” in a frum magazine could de-legitimize that magazine. Will this line get the cut? Will the whole article get the cut?
In today’s world, and in my (attempted) emotionally healthy world, I have learned that it’s good to actually lean into discomfort a bit. To discuss difficult topics, to be OK with not being OK. And that it’s all part of being “normal”. Pain is normal.
My husband and I made a pact early on that we would be straight up with our kids as soon as they were old enough to formulate questions on their own. We would use real names for body parts, speak openly and honestly about any topic they could come up with, and explain to our children that there is good and bad in this world, happy and sad, highs and lows, healthy desire and sometimes the need for control, and that there is a time and a place for (almost) everything.
It was always important that we exposed our kids to issues on our own terms, in our own way.
Firstly, so they don’t spread untruths like “a mom gets pregnant when the dad toasts watermelon seeds and she swallows them” (yes one of my kids heard that one), secondly, so they don’t learn from exposure – unable to properly file these experiences in their brains, but mostly so that we are constantly exercising healthy dialogue. We wanted an open and honest relationship where our children would not feel judged and always feel comfortable talking to us.
Did it work? Not sure. I sure hope so… There are never any guarantees in life.
Every once in a while I get a glimpse that reminds me I'm on the right path about open and honest dialogue. My favorite example was 5 years after that first talk of the birds and the bees, I got a call from my son’s teacher.
“Mrs. Shapiro, I just wanted to let you know that I started teaching your son’s class 7 Habits of Highly Effective Teens, and I’m so sorry that I didn’t realize on time that there was a chapter on sex. The class got really silly about it so I was thinking I should abort the lesson plan.”
My heart skipped a beat. And I continued to listen...
“I was so impressed with your son. He came up to me after class and begged me to be patient with the kids. He wanted to make sure that I understood how important it was to discuss the topic with the class, even if they were being immature about it. He was so concerned that if the other kids in the class never had the opportunity to have open and honest discussion about sex, then they would never know that there is so much potential kedusha (holiness) when it’s at the right time.”
I literally cried tears of pride.
Over the years some really great questions have continued to pop up at young ages. Questions about mental health, about homelessness, about death, and about suffering, among many.
The topic of “when is the right time to talk to kids about difficult topics” is the big question that comes up quite a bit in my work with Margaret’s Legacy, an organization that develops curricular resources to teach young students about the Holocaust in a palatable way.
The Holocaust is another one of those sensitive topics.
I was talking to one of my colleagues recently, Carl Evans, who Margaret’s Legacy and Project Proactive are working with to develop a new program called “A Generation of Hope”. He is a mental health educator at a successful peer-support / suicide prevention non-profit organization called “Hope for the Day”. He shared studies that show that the earlier children are exposed to challenges coupled with stories of resilience, allowing for healthy dialogue, the more likely they are to develop effective coping strategies as adults.
So after all of this… when exactly is the right time?
Sorry to disappoint you… the right time is something you will have to establish for yourself.
You must feel disappointed.
Did you really think I had all of the answers? I’m flattered, but nothing is that easy.
But… what I will say is that for those of you who are skeptical of talking to children early on about sensitive topics, you may want to consider 3 ideas;
If children are old enough to experience the loss of a loved one, to be bullied on the playground, or discriminated against for things beyond their control, then they are old enough to talk about those topics. They MUST become old enough to deal with it, to explore it, to be allowed to feel what they feel, and learn to effect change - becoming a part of a shifting culture.
If their friends are old enough to tell them about their personal issues, then it’s your obligation as parents and educators to give your child the tools to deal with it. It’s really a tough one.
I know it’s a natural instinct to want to protect children if they are not actively dealing with a challenge, and it’s tempting to keep them in a bubble for as long as you can, but they will be exposed at some point… and the question really is, do you want them exposed on your terms or would you rather clean up the mess when they are exposed in a more painful way?
Before they learn it “on the streets”, you have the power to control the narrative and give your children healthy tools they need to build character and resilience, instead of fear and anxiety.
Originally published in Nashim Magazine